James Hardie vs Alside Reviews: A Comprehensive Comparison

Choosing the right siding for your home is a significant decision, impacting its curb appeal, protection from the elements, and overall value. Two prominent names in the siding industry are James Hardie and Alside. James Hardie is renowned for its fiber cement siding, while Alside offers a wide range of vinyl siding options. This article provides a detailed comparison of these two brands to help you make an informed choice.

Understanding the Basics: James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding

James Hardie is the leading manufacturer of fiber cement siding in North America. Fiber cement is a composite material made of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. This combination results in a durable, long-lasting siding option that offers a realistic wood-like appearance. James Hardie siding is known for its resistance to pests, fire, and rot, making it a popular choice for homeowners seeking both beauty and durability.

Key Features of James Hardie Siding:

James Hardie siding boasts several compelling features:

• Durability: Resistant to warping, cracking, rotting, and pests.
• Fire Resistance: Non-combustible and can help protect your home from fire damage.
• Weather Resistance: Performs well in various climates, resisting damage from rain, snow, sun, and wind.
• Appearance: Offers a realistic wood-grain texture and is available in a wide range of colors and styles.
• Low Maintenance: Requires minimal maintenance compared to wood siding.
• Warranty: Comes with a limited, transferable warranty.

James Hardie offers various product lines, each with its own unique characteristics. The most popular lines include:

• HardiePlank Lap Siding: The most popular and versatile option, offering a classic look.
• HardieShingle Siding: Mimics the look of cedar shingles, adding character and texture.
• HardiePanel Vertical Siding: Provides a modern, streamlined appearance.
• HardieTrim Boards: Used for finishing details around windows, doors, and corners.

Understanding the Basics: Alside Vinyl Siding

Alside is a leading manufacturer of vinyl siding, offering a wide array of styles, colors, and textures to suit various architectural styles and homeowner preferences. Vinyl siding is made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and is known for its affordability, low maintenance, and ease of installation. Alside offers a comprehensive range of vinyl siding products, including insulated and non-insulated options.

Key Features of Alside Vinyl Siding:

Alside vinyl siding presents several attractive features:

• Affordability: Generally less expensive than fiber cement siding.
• Low Maintenance: Requires minimal maintenance; simply wash with soap and water.
• Ease of Installation: Lighter and easier to install than fiber cement siding.
• Variety of Styles: Available in a wide range of colors, textures, and profiles.
• Insulation Options: Insulated vinyl siding can improve energy efficiency.
• Warranty: Comes with a limited lifetime warranty.

Alside offers several vinyl siding product lines, including:

• Charter Oak: A popular, durable vinyl siding option.
• Prodigy: An insulated siding option for enhanced energy efficiency.
• Coventry: A more budget-friendly vinyl siding choice.
• Board & Batten: Vertical vinyl siding for a distinctive look.

A Head-to-Head Comparison: James Hardie vs. Alside

Now, let’s delve into a direct comparison of James Hardie and Alside siding across various factors:

Cost:

James Hardie: Fiber cement siding typically has a higher upfront cost than vinyl siding. The material itself is more expensive, and installation often requires specialized skills, adding to the labor costs. Expect to pay significantly more for James Hardie siding compared to Alside.

Alside: Vinyl siding is generally more affordable than fiber cement siding. The material is less expensive, and installation is typically quicker and easier, resulting in lower labor costs. This makes Alside a more budget-friendly option for many homeowners.

Verdict: Alside wins on cost. If budget is a primary concern, Alside vinyl siding is the more economical choice.

Durability:

James Hardie: Fiber cement siding is exceptionally durable. It’s resistant to warping, cracking, rotting, pests (including termites and woodpeckers), and fire. It can withstand harsh weather conditions, including high winds, hail, and extreme temperatures. With proper installation and maintenance, James Hardie siding can last for 50 years or more.

Alside: Vinyl siding is durable, but it’s not as resistant to damage as fiber cement. It can be susceptible to cracking, warping, and fading over time, especially in extreme weather conditions. While modern vinyl siding is more durable than older versions, it may not last as long as fiber cement. The lifespan of vinyl siding is typically 20-40 years.

Verdict: James Hardie wins on durability. Fiber cement offers superior resistance to various types of damage and has a longer lifespan.

Aesthetics:

James Hardie: Fiber cement siding offers a realistic wood-grain texture and is available in a wide range of colors and styles. It can be painted to match any desired color scheme, and the color is baked-on for long-lasting beauty with Hardie’s ColorPlus Technology. This provides a sophisticated and upscale look that enhances curb appeal. Because of the material’s weight and rigidity, it installs straighter and looks more substantial than vinyl.

Alside: Vinyl siding is available in a wide range of colors, textures, and profiles. While it can mimic the look of wood, it often doesn’t have the same realistic appearance as fiber cement. However, advancements in vinyl siding technology have improved its aesthetic appeal. The color is molded into the vinyl, so scratches and dents are less noticeable.

Verdict: James Hardie wins on aesthetics, particularly for those seeking a natural wood look. While Alside offers variety, fiber cement provides a more authentic and upscale appearance.

Maintenance:

James Hardie: Fiber cement siding requires minimal maintenance. It doesn’t need to be painted as frequently as wood siding. Regular cleaning with a garden hose is typically sufficient to remove dirt and debris. You may need to repaint it every 10-15 years, depending on the climate and the paint quality.

Alside: Vinyl siding is incredibly low-maintenance. It doesn’t require painting and can be easily cleaned with soap and water. This makes it a convenient option for homeowners who want to minimize upkeep.

Verdict: Alside wins on maintenance. Vinyl siding requires virtually no maintenance beyond occasional cleaning.

Installation:

James Hardie: Installing fiber cement siding requires specialized skills and tools. It’s heavier and more difficult to cut and handle than vinyl siding. Proper installation is crucial to ensure its longevity and performance. It’s recommended to hire a certified James Hardie installer.

Alside: Vinyl siding is lighter and easier to install than fiber cement. While professional installation is still recommended, it’s generally less complex and requires less specialized equipment.

Verdict: Alside wins on ease of installation. Vinyl siding is quicker and easier to install, resulting in lower labor costs.

Environmental Impact:

James Hardie: Fiber cement siding is made from sustainable materials, including cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. It’s also durable and long-lasting, reducing the need for frequent replacements. However, the manufacturing process can be energy-intensive.

Alside: Vinyl siding is made from PVC, a petroleum-based product. The manufacturing process can release harmful emissions. However, vinyl siding is recyclable, and some manufacturers use recycled materials in their products.

Verdict: It’s a close call. James Hardie utilizes more sustainable raw materials but has a more energy-intensive manufacturing process. Alside uses petroleum-based materials but offers recycling options. The environmental impact depends on various factors, including the specific manufacturing processes and recycling practices.

Warranty:

James Hardie: James Hardie siding comes with a limited, transferable warranty. The warranty covers manufacturing defects and typically lasts for 30 years. However, the warranty may be prorated over time.

Alside: Alside offers a limited lifetime warranty on its vinyl siding products. The warranty covers manufacturing defects and may be transferable to subsequent homeowners. However, it’s essential to review the warranty details carefully to understand the coverage limitations.

Verdict: Alside wins on warranty. A lifetime warranty provides greater peace of mind compared to a limited 30-year warranty.

Detailed Comparison Table

To summarize the key differences, here’s a comparison table:

Feature	James Hardie	Alside
Material	Fiber Cement	Vinyl
Cost	Higher	Lower
Durability	Excellent	Good
Aesthetics	Realistic Wood Look	Wide Variety of Styles
Maintenance	Low	Very Low
Installation	Requires Specialized Skills	Easier
Environmental Impact	Sustainable Materials, Energy-Intensive Manufacturing	Petroleum-Based, Recyclable
Warranty	Limited, Transferable (30 years)	Limited Lifetime, Transferable

Considering Climate and Location

The best siding choice also depends on your climate and location. Here’s how James Hardie and Alside perform in different environments:

Humid Climates:

James Hardie: Fiber cement is highly resistant to moisture and rot, making it an excellent choice for humid climates. It won’t warp or buckle due to humidity, unlike some wood siding options.

Alside: Vinyl siding is also resistant to moisture, but it’s essential to choose a high-quality product with proper ventilation to prevent moisture buildup behind the siding.

Cold Climates:

James Hardie: Fiber cement can withstand freezing temperatures without cracking or warping. However, it’s important to ensure proper installation to prevent water from seeping behind the siding and freezing.

Alside: Vinyl siding can become brittle in extreme cold and may be more prone to cracking. Insulated vinyl siding can provide added protection against the cold and improve energy efficiency.

Hot and Sunny Climates:

James Hardie: Fiber cement is resistant to fading and sun damage, maintaining its appearance for years. Hardie’s ColorPlus technology is specifically designed to resist fading.

Alside: Vinyl siding can fade over time due to prolonged exposure to sunlight. Choose a siding with UV protection to minimize fading.

Coastal Areas:

James Hardie: Fiber cement is resistant to salt spray and wind damage, making it a suitable option for coastal areas. However, it’s essential to choose a product with a durable finish to resist corrosion.

Alside: Vinyl siding can also perform well in coastal areas, but it’s important to choose a product that’s specifically designed to withstand saltwater exposure. Look for siding with corrosion-resistant hardware.

The Importance of Professional Installation

Regardless of whether you choose James Hardie or Alside siding, professional installation is crucial. Proper installation ensures that the siding performs as intended and maximizes its lifespan. A poorly installed siding can lead to problems such as:

• Water damage
• Mold growth
• Warping and cracking
• Increased energy bills

When choosing a siding contractor, look for someone with experience installing the specific type of siding you’ve chosen. Ask for references and check their online reviews. A certified James Hardie installer is highly recommended for James Hardie siding, as they have undergone specialized training and are familiar with the proper installation techniques.

James Hardie Specific Considerations: HardieZone System

James Hardie offers a unique HardieZone system, which tailors the siding product to the specific climate where it will be installed. This ensures optimal performance and durability in different regions. The HardieZone system divides North America into different zones based on climate factors such as temperature, humidity, and UV exposure. Each zone has a specific set of Hardie products that are designed to withstand the local weather conditions.

For example, the HZ5 product line is designed for colder climates and is resistant to freezing temperatures and snow. The HZ10 product line is designed for warmer climates and is resistant to heat and humidity. By choosing the right HardieZone product for your area, you can ensure that your siding will perform optimally for years to come.

Alside Specific Considerations: Insulated Vinyl Siding

Alside offers insulated vinyl siding options that can significantly improve your home’s energy efficiency. Insulated siding has a layer of foam insulation attached to the back of the vinyl, which helps to reduce heat transfer and lower energy bills. Insulated siding can also make your home more comfortable by reducing drafts and temperature fluctuations.

Alside’s Prodigy line is a popular insulated siding option. It features a thick foam insulation layer that provides excellent thermal performance. Insulated vinyl siding can be a worthwhile investment, especially in areas with extreme temperatures.

Long-Term Value and ROI

When considering the cost of siding, it’s important to think about the long-term value and return on investment (ROI). While James Hardie siding has a higher upfront cost, its superior durability and lifespan can result in lower long-term costs. Fiber cement siding requires less frequent maintenance and replacement compared to vinyl siding.

Both James Hardie and Alside siding can increase your home’s value and curb appeal. A well-maintained home with attractive siding is more appealing to potential buyers. Choosing a high-quality siding material can be a smart investment that pays off in the long run.

Beyond Siding: Trim and Accessories

In addition to the siding itself, consider the trim and accessories. Trim is used to finish the edges of the siding and create a polished look. Accessories such as corner posts, window and door trim, and soffit and fascia can enhance the overall appearance of your home.

James Hardie offers HardieTrim boards, which are made from the same fiber cement material as the siding. HardieTrim provides a seamless and durable finish. Alside offers a variety of vinyl trim and accessories to complement its siding products. Choose trim and accessories that match the style and color of your siding.

Color Options and Design Considerations

Both James Hardie and Alside offer a wide range of color options to suit various architectural styles and homeowner preferences. James Hardie’s ColorPlus Technology provides a baked-on finish that resists fading and chipping. Alside offers a variety of colors that are molded into the vinyl, so scratches and dents are less noticeable.

When choosing a siding color, consider the style of your home, the surrounding landscape, and your personal preferences. Neutral colors such as white, gray, and beige are classic choices that complement a wide range of architectural styles. Bold colors can add personality and make your home stand out. Dark colors may absorb more heat in sunny climates.

Addressing Common Concerns and Misconceptions

There are some common concerns and misconceptions about James Hardie and Alside siding that are worth addressing:

James Hardie Concerns:

• Cost: Some homeowners are concerned about the higher upfront cost of James Hardie siding. However, it’s important to consider the long-term value and ROI.
• Installation Complexity: Installing fiber cement siding requires specialized skills and tools, which can be a concern for DIYers. However, hiring a certified installer ensures proper installation and maximizes the siding’s lifespan.
• Weight: Fiber cement siding is heavier than vinyl siding, which can make it more difficult to handle. However, professional installers have the necessary equipment and expertise to handle the weight.

Alside Concerns:

• Durability: Some homeowners are concerned about the durability of vinyl siding compared to fiber cement. However, modern vinyl siding is more durable than older versions and can last for 20-40 years with proper maintenance.
• Appearance: Some homeowners feel that vinyl siding doesn’t have the same realistic appearance as fiber cement. However, advancements in vinyl siding technology have improved its aesthetic appeal.
• Fading: Vinyl siding can fade over time due to prolonged exposure to sunlight. However, choosing a siding with UV protection can minimize fading.

Making the Final Decision

Choosing between James Hardie and Alside siding is a personal decision that depends on your individual needs, budget, and preferences. Consider the following factors when making your decision:

• Budget: How much are you willing to spend on siding?
• Durability: How important is long-term durability and resistance to damage?
• Aesthetics: What style and appearance do you prefer?
• Maintenance: How much time and effort are you willing to spend on maintenance?
• Climate: What are the weather conditions in your area?
• Long-Term Value: How important is long-term value and ROI?

If you prioritize durability and aesthetics and are willing to invest more upfront, James Hardie siding may be the better choice. If you prioritize affordability and low maintenance, Alside vinyl siding may be a more suitable option.

Seeking Professional Advice

It’s always a good idea to seek professional advice before making a final decision. Consult with a reputable siding contractor who can assess your home’s needs and recommend the best siding option for your situation. They can provide you with a detailed estimate and answer any questions you may have.

Conclusion

Both James Hardie and Alside are reputable siding manufacturers that offer high-quality products. James Hardie fiber cement siding is known for its superior durability and realistic wood appearance, while Alside vinyl siding is known for its affordability and low maintenance. By carefully considering your needs, budget, and preferences, you can choose the siding that’s right for your home. Remember to prioritize professional installation to ensure the siding performs as intended and maximizes its lifespan.